|
Reviews For When the Boat Comes In
Author's Response: Thanks for the review: I try to make my writing as realistic as possible and give each character a discernable 'voice', both in their writing and speech. I can't really answer your question but I will comment that, as Jean is in an emotionally vulnerable position and Severus is a strong, kind, steady character, it's a 50/50 chance that, at some point, she'll notice his attractions.
It's nice to see the Malfoys be decent in a story. I think if the situation in cannon had been different, they would have been okay to be around. Good job on the chapter. Mourning is always so hard to write. Author's Response: Thanks ^^ I think the Malfoys have some first rate qualities, e.g. their love for each other, and, had Harry accepted Draco's hand in the beginning, the situation might have evolved very differently. I'm glad you liked Harry's letter; it's the first time I've written one from him and I really wanted to show that, although he is bright and empathetic, he's still very much a child. (In his academic acheivements, I've put Harry at the level which he should have reached in the canon if he'd applied himself. In the canon he spends most of his year mucking around with Ron, playing chess, exploding snap and generally frittering away study time.) Mourning is hard to write because people mourn in so many ways; some go numb- for weeks, months, even years, others become furiously angry, many go into denial and a few, the luckiest ones, are able to weep and heal. And, of course, people go through good minutes and bad minutes, so there's inconsistancy but, at the same time, one has to be consistant in that inconsistancy or the character's behaviour won't be realistic. I hope that my portrayal of mourning was believable.
Author's Response: Thanks for the review ^^ I'm glad you liked it
Author's Response: Thanks ^^. I think most 11 year old boys would consider it base treachery to gather homework for a friend (considering that they'll use any excuse to get out of doing their homework lol!) Theo, however, is very serious and bookish and, as Hermione is his study-buddy, he knows enough about her to put two and two together ^^.
Author's Response: Thanks ^^ I hope you'll enjoy the next two chapters :)
Yes, poor Hermione. I'm sorry that her father died, but glad that her mother was spared. At least they'll have one another. It has always made sense to me that Voldemort would be interested in going after the Grangers...they're Muggles and their daughter is one of Harry's closest friends. I didn't want something to happen to them, but I was a little surprised that the thought never seemed to cross anyone's mind, at least til DH. Looking forward to more! Author's Response: Thanks ^^. I really wanted Quirrell to be innocent in this fic and, when I was planning the final scene, I thought I could do a mirroring of Harry's bonding with Hissy, i.e. Voldemort driven out by basilisk venom (though, in this instance, he wasn't killed) and, thereby, give Quirrell the chance to make a confession. (It also neatly mirrored Fawkes saving Harry in CoS ^^) Hope you enjoy the next few chapters
Poor Hermione. I'm glad that her mother was unwell and thus, survived the attack. It would have been beyond horrible if she had lost both of her parents in one fatal blow. I have a feeling that Harry (and Severus) is right about the reason the Grangers were attacked; it was quite simply a way to get Severus out of the way. Author's Response: Thanks for the review. Lol: I think Draco's essay idea was motivated by his desire to wriggle out of a lecture by Professor Snape than a knowledge of his father, who is too soft-hearted to deny his son anything, meaning that the usual punishment (grounding), gets 'forgotten' the moment Draco wants to visit a friend, go to a party, etc. Yes, I didn't have the heart to kill off both Hermione's parents and, besides, it works better (for Voldemort) this way because it ensures that not only Dumbledore but Severus is out of the way. If Jean hadn't been unwell, Voldie would have had his puppet wait until Mr or Mrs Granger left the practice before bombing it or, alternately, cast avada kedavra on one or the other.
Author's Response: Thanks for the review. I know, I hated doing this but it was necessary and I comforted myself by remembering J. K. Rowling did this (i.e. killed of a character just before the end of the story) thrice in the canon; with Cedric, Sirius and Dumbledore.
Author's Response: Thanks ^^ I'm glad you enjoyed it. Yes, I do plan a sequel but I need to finish off my other stories first. At the end of this fic, I'm going to ask the readers which story I should concentrate on next: 'Inverted' or 'Order of the Pegasus'. (Well, after I've finished my contest fic, that is lol)
Author's Response: Thanks ^^. Its sad but I thought that, to get both Dumbledore and Severus out of Hogwarts all night, I had to plot something significant and a magical murder in a muggle street, which left the other muggle spouse highly vulnerable, was potent enough to ensure the Headmaster and Head of Slytherin's absense and, as Hermione is the only muggleborn in Slytherin, her parents are in the best fit. |
Powered by eFiction 3.5 |